The Roof Upgrade That Will Make Your Neighbors Jealous: Designer Shingles
Let's face it. Most homeowners don't get particularly excited about replacing their roof. Usually, it's something that needs to be done because the existing roof is old, leaking, damaged, or simply reaching the end of its useful life. It's an expensive home improvement project that often feels more like a necessary expense than something you actually want to spend money on. And for many homeowners, the goal is straightforward: get a good roof installed by a reputable contractor, choose a color that looks decent, and hopefully not have to think about it again for a very long time.

But what if you're looking at it the wrong way? What if replacing your roof could be an opportunity to dramatically improve the appearance of your home instead of simply restoring its ability to keep the rain out? What if the roof itself could become one of the most attractive features of your house? That's where designer roofing shingles come in. And if you've never seriously considered them, you might be surprised by just how different your home could look.
The Problem With Today's Roofs: Everybody Has the Same One
There's something of a conformity problem in residential roofing today. Drive through almost any neighborhood in Maryland or Pennsylvania and look at the roofs. Chances are, you'll see one house after another covered in the same basic architectural shingle, often in some variation of charcoal, weathered wood, or gray. The houses may be completely different in size, design, and value, but the roofs look remarkably similar.
It wasn't always this way. Years ago, traditional three-tab shingles were everywhere. When dimensional architectural shingles became widely popular, they were a significant improvement in appearance. Their layered construction created more depth, texture, and shadowing than the flat, repetitive appearance of three-tab shingles. Homeowners embraced them, contractors recommended them, and eventually they became the standard choice for residential roof replacements. And there's nothing wrong with that. Today's quality architectural shingles are attractive, dependable, and an excellent choice for many homes.

But somewhere along the way, it seems like everyone forgot that other roofing styles existed. Architectural shingles became so common that many homeowners don't even consider alternatives. They assume that choosing a new roof means selecting one of a dozen colors from essentially the same shingle design. The result is that practically every residential roof starts looking alike. It's not that architectural shingles are unattractive. It's that they've become so familiar that they rarely make a house stand out anymore.
Enter Designer Roofing Shingles
Designer shingles, sometimes called luxury shingles, are asphalt roofing products manufactured to create a more distinctive appearance than conventional architectural shingles. Some are designed to resemble natural slate. Others imitate the heavy, textured appearance of traditional cedar shakes. Still others use unusual shapes, staggered patterns, deeper shadow lines, and more substantial profiles to create an entirely different look.
The difference can be dramatic. A standard architectural shingle generally produces a relatively uniform appearance across the roof. A designer shingle can introduce larger patterns, more pronounced texture, and visual depth that changes how the entire house is perceived. Instead of the roof simply blending into the background, it becomes an intentional part of the home's architecture.
And because these products are asphalt-based, homeowners can achieve some of the appearance of traditional slate or wood roofing without necessarily taking on the cost, weight, maintenance, or installation requirements associated with those materials. That doesn't mean designer asphalt shingles are identical to natural slate or cedar, but they can provide a remarkably attractive alternative.
Not Every House Needs a Designer Roof
Before going any further, I want to make something clear: I don't believe every homeowner should spend extra money on designer shingles. In fact, there are plenty of houses where I would probably recommend against it.
If you own a home with a relatively low-pitched roof that's barely visible from the street, spending thousands of dollars on a premium roofing design might not make much sense. If you can only see a narrow strip of shingles above the gutters, you're simply not going to appreciate the visual difference enough to justify the additional expense. The same may be true of certain homes where the roof is largely hidden by architectural features or where the homeowner has no particular interest in changing the appearance of the house.

But if you own a colonial, Cape Cod, contemporary, or another home with substantial roof exposure, the equation changes. A steep roof with large, visible sections can represent a significant percentage of what people see when they look at your house. On some homes, the roof is arguably one of the most prominent exterior features. And in more upscale neighborhoods, where homeowners often invest considerable money in landscaping, siding, windows, trim, and other exterior improvements, the roof can be an overlooked opportunity to make the entire property look more distinctive.
You might spend thousands upgrading your front door, adding decorative trim, or improving your landscaping. Yet when it comes time to replace the roof, you select the same shingle that's on practically every other house on the street. There's nothing inherently wrong with that choice, but if your goal is to make your home stand out, I think it's worth exploring the alternatives.
What Do Designer Shingles Actually Look Like?
There are several different approaches to designer roofing, and the right choice depends heavily on the architecture of your home. Some products create the appearance of slate, with irregular shapes and pronounced shadow lines that work particularly well on traditional, colonial, and more formal homes. Others resemble cedar shakes, offering a rustic, substantial appearance that can complement Cape Cods, larger custom homes, and houses with prominent rooflines.
CertainTeed, one of the manufacturers we work with, offers several examples worth exploring. Its Grand Manor shingles are designed to create the substantial, dimensional appearance of natural slate. Carriage House shingles have distinctive shaped edges that produce a more decorative, old-world appearance. Belmont offers another slate-inspired look, while Presidential Shake and Presidential Shake TL are designed to resemble traditional wood shakes with pronounced texture and depth. These aren't simply standard architectural shingles in different colors. They create noticeably different roof patterns and visual effects.
And that's really the point. When you're considering a designer shingle, you're not just choosing between black, brown, and gray. You're choosing the style of the roof itself. Much like selecting between traditional horizontal siding, cedar-style shakes, and board-and-batten siding, different roofing profiles can produce entirely different architectural results.

Are Designer Shingles Better Than Regular Architectural Shingles?
That depends on what you mean by better. From an appearance standpoint, I think the right designer shingle on the right house can be a substantial upgrade. But that doesn't mean every designer product automatically provides better weather protection or lasts longer than every standard architectural shingle.
Many premium roofing products feature heavier construction, additional layers, or specialized performance characteristics. However, wind resistance, impact resistance, warranty coverage, and other specifications vary by manufacturer and product. A more expensive shingle isn't automatically the best-performing option in every category. The roof's installation, ventilation, flashing, underlayment, and other components remain extremely important regardless of which shingle you select.
For homeowners who simply want a quality, dependable roof at a reasonable price, a good architectural shingle may be the ideal choice. But for someone who's already investing in a complete roof replacement and wants to make a noticeable improvement to the appearance of the house, I think designer shingles deserve serious consideration.
How Much More Do Designer Roofing Shingles Cost?
This is where most homeowners lose interest before they've even started. They hear words like designer, luxury, or premium and immediately assume the price is going to be outrageous. And to be fair, some designer roofing products are considerably more expensive than standard architectural shingles. The materials can cost significantly more, certain products require different installation techniques or accessories, and some take additional labor to install properly.
But here's something homeowners often overlook: You're already paying to replace the roof. You're already paying for the tear-off, disposal, underlayment, flashing work, installation labor, and the other components involved in a complete roofing project. Depending on the designer shingle you choose, some of those costs may remain relatively similar. That means the additional investment isn't necessarily the cost of an entirely new roof. It's the difference between the standard shingle system and the upgraded one, including any additional materials and labor the upgrade requires.

That difference can still be substantial, and I wouldn't suggest otherwise. But it may be considerably less than you imagine, particularly when compared with the total amount you're already planning to spend. The only way to know whether it's worthwhile is to see the actual numbers for your house.
Our Online Roof Calculator Lets You See the Actual Upgrade Prices
One of the reasons we developed our Instant Online Roof Quote Calculator was to make roofing prices easier for homeowners to understand. Traditionally, if you wanted to explore designer shingles, you'd have to schedule an appointment, meet with a contractor, review samples, and ask for separate estimates on the different products you were considering. And even then, you might have to wait for revised quotes before you could make an informed comparison.
We wanted to simplify that process. With our online calculator, homeowners in Maryland and Pennsylvania can start by receiving an actual replacement price for a standard architectural shingle roof. From there, they can browse the available designer shingle upgrade options and see the actual price difference for their particular roof. Instead of wondering whether a premium shingle might add $2,000, $5,000, or $15,000 to the project, you can explore the available choices and see what those upgrades would cost.
That's a big difference from reading generic articles about designer shingle pricing. Your roof may have a different size, pitch, complexity, or number of architectural features than someone else's. The cost of upgrading a relatively simple roof won't necessarily be the same as upgrading a large, complicated roof with multiple valleys, dormers, and steep sections. Our calculator takes the characteristics of your home into account when developing the estimate.

You can explore the options without having to provide your phone number or email address just to see pricing. And if you decide that a standard architectural shingle is the better value for your home, that's perfectly fine. At least you've had the opportunity to compare the alternatives rather than automatically choosing the same product everyone else seems to have.
Choosing the Right Designer Shingle Still Requires Some Thought
Just because a shingle looks beautiful in a photograph doesn't necessarily mean it's the right choice for your house. Roof color, texture, and pattern need to work with your siding, brick, shutters, trim, and the overall architectural style of the home. A heavily textured, rustic-looking shingle might look fantastic on one property and completely out of place on another. Likewise, an elegant slate-inspired shingle might complement a traditional colonial beautifully but feel unnecessarily formal on a simpler ranch-style home.
This is one reason I still believe an in-person consultation is important, even when homeowners have already explored their options online. Photographs are helpful, but actual samples allow you to better appreciate the shingle's color, thickness, texture, and construction. We can also evaluate how visible the roof is from the ground and whether a particular upgrade is likely to deliver the appearance you're hoping for.
I also encourage homeowners to look at photographs of complete roofs rather than relying entirely on small shingle samples. A product can look one way when you're holding a sample in your hand and quite different when it's installed across a large roof surface. The overall pattern, shadowing, and color variation become much more apparent when you see the product on an actual house.
A New Roof Doesn't Have to Be Just Another Necessary Expense
If your roof is failing, replacing it may not be optional. You need to protect your home, and that should always be the first priority. But that doesn't mean you have to approach the project as nothing more than an expensive repair.

Think about how much attention homeowners give to choosing siding colors, replacement windows, front doors, landscaping, and other exterior improvements. Those decisions are often made with curb appeal in mind. We want our homes to look attractive, reflect our tastes, and perhaps stand out a little from the houses around us. Yet the roof, which can occupy an enormous amount of visible exterior space, is often treated as an afterthought.
I think that's a missed opportunity. If you're already planning to spend thousands of dollars replacing your roof, why not at least explore what a more distinctive shingle might do for your home? You may decide the upgrade isn't worth the additional expense. Or you may discover that the difference in appearance is exactly what your house has been missing.
And yes, you might even make a few neighbors jealous.
See What Designer Shingles Would Cost on Your Home
At JP Construction Services, we've been installing and replacing residential roofs throughout Maryland and Pennsylvania since 2005. We understand that every homeowner has different priorities, and we don't believe everyone needs the most expensive roofing product available. But we do believe homeowners should know what their options are and what those options actually cost.
Our Instant Online Roof Quote Calculator lets you get started in approximately 60 seconds. Get your price for a standard architectural shingle roof, browse available designer roofing upgrades, and see the additional cost for your home. No obligation, no lengthy sales presentation, and no phone number or email address required just to see your price.
Prefer to discuss your options in person? Visit JP Construction Services or call (877) 846-9566 to schedule a free roofing consultation.

We serve homeowners throughout Harford, Baltimore, Carroll, Cecil, Howard, Frederick, Montgomery, and Anne Arundel counties in Maryland, as well as York, Lancaster, and Chester counties in Pennsylvania.































